6 Red Flags to Watch When Hiring Reroofing Contractors

After the storm, pounding rainfall, or heavy snowfall, neighbourhoods in Melbourne are typically flooded with roofing salespeople and flyers trying to establish their business in one of the few states with no state licensing requirements for roofing companies. 

You should know that there are good roofers, bad contractors, and roofers who fall somewhere in between in the roofing industry. Homeowners often find it daunting to research and choose roofing contractors themselves. 

You might be tempted to opt for the least expensive option. But when hiring roofers, you often get what you pay for. Instead, working with skilled and trustworthy roofing or reroofing contractors is always best for optimal results. 

So, how can you weed out good roofers from bad ones? To help, this article compiles a list of six red flags you need to be aware of when hiring roofing contractors.

Warning signs to watch for before hiring a reroofing contractor.

They are not Local

When looking for roofing contractors, you must consider whether they are local. 

Out of the town, roofers are usually storm chasers. They show up when a weather-related event, such as storms, heavy rains, hurricanes, etc, hits a particular area. 

Such roofers’ work the storm’ or other weather-related events and immediately leave the town, making them unable or unwilling to service any warranty they promised you before commencing the roofing project. 

In addition, storm chasers don’t have any proper license to work in specific areas or expertise. They jump into an opportunity to earn extra money before leaving the town. 

It will help avoid storm chasers and, instead, look for local roofing or reroofing contractors known for their work quality. Moreover, these roofers can immediately come back to fix any issue with your roof. 

Working with local contractors also ensures they know the local building codes and regulations and provide services accordingly. 

They are not Licensed or Insured

Working with a licensed and insured roofing professional is always beneficial as it protects your home and roofers working on the project from unforeseen accidents or damages. 

A good rule of thumb is to ask the shortlisted roofing contractor for proof of licensing and insurance before signing any contract. It will help you know whether the contractor is professionally trained and complies with the local building codes. 

Moreover, see to it the reroofing contractor’s license is up-to-date, and the insurance policy covers any damages to your property or home that might take place during the roofing project.

They Don’t Have Portfolio or References

When living in an area prone to hot and unpredictable weather, you might have to deal with roofing contractors trying to take advantage of many roofs that need repair or replacement. Such areas tend to see many ‘fly-by-night’ roofing contractors who try to make quick cash by hawking on vulnerable customers. 

A major red flag for such roofers is that they don’t have any past work. Shady roofing companies will not supply any portfolio or references and will simply stop responding. 

You should know that reputable roofing and reroofing contractors always have a portfolio and references from their prior jobs. The contractors who are proud of their skills and work will have no problem giving you photos and videos of completed roofing projects. 

In addition, they will non-hesitantly share a list of references for you to know more about their work. 

Roofing Contractors Asking for Money Upfront

If a roofer asks for money upfront, it could potentially be a red flag. Scammers often target older people by getting partial or full payment upfront and never completing the work or returning the money.

In such cases, demanding partial payment upfront is not the cause of concern, as roofers need some money to purchase the materials required to complete the job. 

However, if a roofing contractor asks for full payment before doing any work, it is generally a cause for alarm. In such a case, you should look for another roofer and not give full payment or insurance checks to any roofing contractor. 

They are not Transparent About Pricing

When working with roof contractors, ensure they are transparent about their pricing. A roofing contractor avoiding giving you the price estimate before working on the roofing project is a major red flag. 

You need to be able to trust that you are getting the best value for your money and that the roofer is not taking advantage of you. 

A trustworthy contractor will always provide you with an estimate for installing a new roof Melbourne, including materials, labour costs, and taxes. 

In addition, they will be ready to answer any questions you have about the cost of your roofing project. If your contractor can’t provide these details, you should look for another roofer.

In addition, before signing the contract, watch out for hidden fees or charges.

They Pressure You to Sign the Dotted Line

Most roofing contractors ask their clients to sign the contract for any roofing job. However, a reliable roofing contractor will know that making a significant repair or replacement purchase takes time. 

A homeowner will need time and space to research, create a budget, and plan for the expenses. Understandable roofing companies will always give their potential clients the room to determine whether or not you want to work with them. 

It’s why any roofing contractor vehemently pressuring you to move forward and sign on the dotted line can be a significant red flag. 

Moreover, a roofing contractor should always be willing to answer your queries honestly regarding the project. Consider it a red flag if a contractor ignores your questions or goes silent when you ask too many questions. 

Concluding Words

When you hire a roofing company to install a new roof Melbourne or repair the old one, consider the above-discussed red flags. 

Always look for local roofing contractors who can best repair or replace your roof, depending on local building codes or weather conditions. 

In addition, they will have a reputation to hold throughout the local area and, thus, provide the best possible services. You should avoid storm chasers or anyone not having a license or insurance and ask for the payment upfront.

Eleven questions worth asking before you sign

Ask every quote the same questions. The answers tell you more than the price does.

  1. What kind of roofing do you specialise in? Tiled roofs behave differently to sheet roofs. A tiler and a metal roofer are not interchangeable, and the detail is in the pointing, valleys and flashings.
  2. Are you licensed and insured? Ask to see it, not just be told.
  3. How long have you traded under this name? Businesses that change name often are worth a second look.
  4. Can I see local jobs you have done? Ideally in your suburb, on a roof like yours.
  5. Which tile brand and profile, and is it still in production? This matters enormously on a repair or an extension, where matching an existing roof may not be possible.
  6. Are the crew employees or subcontractors? Neither is wrong, but you should know who is on your roof and who carries the insurance.
  7. Does the quote include sarking and battens, or only tiles? This is the commonest reason two quotes differ by thousands.
  8. Is scaffolding included, and what safety measures are costed in? Hand-rail, scaffolding or a harness should be in every quote. If one quote is cheaper, check whether safety was simply left out.
  9. What happens if you find rot once the tiles are off? You want to hear that they will photograph it and talk to you before doing extra work.
  10. What guarantee do I get, in writing? Ask separately about the tile manufacturer warranty and the roofer’s own workmanship guarantee — they are different things.
  11. Who removes the old tiles and rubbish? And is the site left swept, with gutters cleared and a magnet run for nails.

Two answers that should concern you

A quote given without anyone getting on the roof. What decides between a repair, a restoration and a replacement sits under the tiles. A number produced from the footpath is either padded to cover the unknowns or will be revised later.

Pressure to decide today. A roof is a considered purchase. Discounts that expire this week are a sales technique, not a price.

How we answer them

Camberwell Potteries Roofing has worked on Melbourne tiled roofs since the 1930s, when the company made the terracotta tiles rather than laying them. Terracotta and concrete only — no metal, Colorbond, polycarbonate or slate.

We are a dual supplier of CSR Monier and Bristile, so the tile suits your roof rather than whatever we stock. Our workmanship is guaranteed for 10 years on a full re-roof and 7 years on a restoration. Safety is always our first priority — hand-rail, scaffolding or a roof harness is used on every job and included in the quote.

And we inspect before we quote, because the alternative is guessing.

Free roof inspection and obligation-free quote. Call 03 9888 7088, Monday to Friday 9:00am to 4:00pm, or send us a message.

Related reading: what a re-roof involves, cost and timeline · do you need a building permit · re-roofing services · roof restoration · roofing FAQs

What our customers say

Google
Andrew McGrath profile picture
Andrew McGrath
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I commend Shane and the team on handling my job for me so professionally, with a friendly and reliable manner, meaning the whole experience exceed my expectations. These things mean a lot to me making this a very good Customer experience. Thank you.
Google
MargeryAnne West profile picture
MargeryAnne West
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Thank you Camberwell Potteries Roofing for the excellent job you have done on our aging roof. The service from across the team was professional, respectful, efficient and reliable, resulting in minimal disruption to us or our neighbours. This is the second time we have needed your service, with the first still looking great, (even though we are no longer living there).
Google
Laura Tomei profile picture
Laura Tomei
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
What can we say but, THANK YOU Camberwell Potteries Roofing! We were reticent to undertake such a large job, but our roof tiles were old and therefore crumbling. Three different households in our street in Glen Iris had their roof restorations done by Camberwell Potteries Roofing, and had nothing but praise for their professionalism, ethics and respect throughout the job, which has taken less than 2 weeks. We are the fourth in our street to recommend this company. We are very happy with our new roof! Thank you again to all the crew!
Google
Leanne Barnes profile picture
Leanne Barnes
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Very happy with the work. Great customer service and a beautiful job, the roof looks amazing - we have had many comments from our neighbours. The team were punctual, respectful and provided excellent workmanship. It was a pleasure to deal with them all and they kept the property clean and tidy! Would highly recommend. Thank you all!
Google
Janice M profile picture
Janice M
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Very happy. Glenn and his team were punctual, respectful and did an amazing job. Thank you Glenn.
Google
Marlene Donovan profile picture
Marlene Donovan
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
From the start, Camberwell Potteries have gone above and beyond. I used them to replace my roof 10 years ago and I was so impressed with their work ethics, their customer service and the beautiful job they did that I got them to replace the roof in our new house. Once again incredible service, bending over backwards to help and a fantastic team run by Glenn for the installation - a beautiful job done! A great Australian company that has been around for thirty years and knows how to do it!  Thank you to the owner of Camberwell Potteries Glen, Mel was amazing at arranging it all and the other Glenn and his team for the installation… thank you all!
Google
Bill Kolivas profile picture
Bill Kolivas
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Very pleased with their work in retiling my roof. New tiles look great. Very professional outfit.
Google
Chevonne Boom profile picture
Chevonne Boom
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Camberwell Potteries Roofing were absolutely amazing. Glen and his team couldn't have been more helpful. Our house being very old and in desperate need of repair had its challenges. They got on with it and we are absolutely delighted with the results. Jules in the office was so delightful and nothing was too much trouble. All in all it has been a fantastic experience and we will have no hesitation recommending Camberwell Potteries Roofing.
Google
Anastasia Kritikos profile picture
Anastasia Kritikos
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Expert roof replacement with excellent customer service and outstanding workmanship for an unbeatable price! I highly recommend Glenn and his team for their friendly professional approach when it came to replacing a large roof on our commercial property. I couldn't be more pleased with the outcome! From start to finish the experience was smooth and professional achieving a quality finish. This substantial job came with issues such as difficult access, and much pressure from neighbouring businesses and was performed during a rainy and windy week. However Glenn and his team from Camberwell Potteries Roofing happily worked through this and achieved the final finished roof (including vacuuming and new insulation in the ceiling) within the timeframe that was promised. The team of roofers arrived on time and quickly got to work. Their efficiency was impressive and their skill and experience was evident. I would not hesitate to use this company again and I cannot recommend them highly enough! The roof looks amazing!
Google
Tatty Samba profile picture
Tatty Samba
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
After so many years I have an awesome roof again, I’m just in love. Camberwell Team was great, very professional, lovely and respectful guys. Recommend +++++